1. Batman vs Superman
2. Batman vs Evil Superman
3. Evil Batman vs Superman
4. Evil Batman vs Evil Superman
Please share your thoughts about this, or correct my arguments haha
Batman fights Superman, both are on character (with moral). A regular fight between these two usually ends up at a draw where Batman is beaten and Superman is subdued (with kryptonite or red sun). This is not a fight to the death, more like a usual best friend feud over an opinion or actions. The outcomes depends on the writer, i'd say Batman dominates 6 out of 10 fights, but it always ends up as a draw.
2. Batman vs Evil Superman
Superman without moral is undoubtedly the most terrifying thing ever. With this, I don't think Batman stand a chance at all, even with prep time. Batman usually avoid using lethal weapon and method early fight, while evil Superman would straight up obliterate Batman. See Injustice for examlple, that evil Superman still has a sliver bit of moral in him and Batman can't beat him. So, Evil Superman takes this 10 out of 10 fights. Evil Supes godstomps.
3. Evil Batman vs Superman
Now Batman is well known on being a master of preparation against his enemies, he'll exploit every weapon he have and every weakness the enemy have. Some people even stated that Batman with prep time is beyond omega level hahaha. Now Superman is not much of a fighter with his moral on, he'll mostly take his enemies attacks, talks to them, then smash their head or subdue them (not kill them). Evil Batman won't hesitate to exploit every weakness Superman has (red sun, his family, every flavors of kryptonite. A great example of this fight is The Batman Who Laughs, where Batman becomes infected with Joker toxin and gone rampage killing every superbeings on his planet. He'll stay 20 steps ahead of everyone and won't hesitate with lethal weapons and methods. I'd say Evil Batman wins 8 out of 10 fights. Evil Batman Stomps.
4. Evil Batman vs Evil Superman
This is the fight that would bring upon the destruction of the universe haha. With a Superman that will straight up punch a hole in your chest and a Batman who is 20 steps ahead of you with every arsenal the league has and every weakness Superman has, I think Batman would take 4 out of 10 fights, depends on the situations. Mad.
Please share your thoughts about this, or correct my arguments haha