Cakes Mafia [Mafia + NE win]

Started by Josephine [1923258] Wiki Contributor on 20 Jul 2018 in Fun & Games.

1,948 replies · 3.29k views · thread synced 23 Sep 2026 · 3 days ago · View on torn.com

Posts archived: 1,949 / 1,949 posts (100%) · the total is Torn's reply count + the opening post at the last fetch

Raius [2045501] 26 Jul 2018, 00:21 TCT · #941

No, the attacker wouldve also died, likely. unless moon was attacked directly.. and i still want to lynch zak today. it's very likely he's lying.

rainbowsaurus [1884204] 26 Jul 2018, 00:23 TCT · #942

are you reading the same thing I am?

"Every night, you must target a player. If they are to be killed, you will save them and die in their place."

where does it say the attacker dies too?

Proxima [1879587] Wiki Editor 26 Jul 2018, 00:24 TCT · #943 · edited

Yeah attacker dying wouldn't make sense there at all, who kills Moon otherwise?

well, unless it's like this

[image: media1.giphy.com]

Raius [2045501] 26 Jul 2018, 00:24 TCT · #944

Ah, sorry, it's in my memory :p I'm so used to TOS roles.

Hcom3 [2003693] 26 Jul 2018, 00:24 TCT · #945

vote zakattak418

Same Role name? But 2 different abilities? Not very likely.

Raius [2045501] 26 Jul 2018, 00:25 TCT · #946

in TOS, bodyguard dies while protecting someone, killing the attacker. If bodyguard is targeted directly, they outright die ;p

Raius [2045501] 26 Jul 2018, 00:26 TCT · #947

Very unlikely. I'm guessing he just chose one role that he could very easily say 'oh yeah, he's red' or 'oh yeah, he's green.', since as mafia, you already know who's green :p So, zak, what do you have for today?

vote zakattak

Raius [2045501] 26 Jul 2018, 00:27 TCT · #948

so, we've lost 5 greens to kill 1 red. well, 5 greens to kill 1 red, and zak soon.

There may be a role like 'imposter' that can steal someone's role name or smth.

Josephine [1923258] Wiki Contributor 26 Jul 2018, 00:32 TCT · #949

[image: cdn.discordapp.com]

Hellcat [2100232] 26 Jul 2018, 00:34 TCT · #950

WHAT I HAVE A CAKE NOW???? AGHHHHHHHH HALP THE CAKE KILLER DONT COME FOR ME PLEASE

rainbowsaurus [1884204] 26 Jul 2018, 00:34 TCT · #951

im kinda glad I don't have cake yet :P

but also kinda sad :(

Hellcat [2100232] 26 Jul 2018, 00:35 TCT · #952

Suddenly, she felt someone behind her, and froze.

"You are not worthy of that cake."

I don't think so. I think the neutral killer killed her, same as they killed Hino. I think the neutral killer can only kill people with cakes maybe, or thats what they wants us to think.

Hellcat [2100232] 26 Jul 2018, 00:45 TCT · #953 · edited

Though the town protective is dead already but if there are more (I doubt theres only one) I would think they should focus more on protecting people with cakes as they are most likely to die from the cake killer. Its at least better than randomly going onto someone and hoping they get attacked

Edit: Well actually nvm going on the investigatives would make sense too

Yasen [1924620] 26 Jul 2018, 00:48 TCT · #954

Coughs in OP stealth edit

Auriel [2017726] 26 Jul 2018, 02:02 TCT · #955

Hmm...

So I agree, the flavour of Ninivah's death doesn't seem to fit a mafia kill. But MoonLily's sounds like the overzealous cake-loving killer, not like the mafia either.

I wonder if we possibly didn't have a mafia kill last night. I'm tempted to ask if anybody prevented another player from taking their action last night. Might have discovered a mafia killer if so...

Does it read that way to you guys too?

Raius [2045501] 26 Jul 2018, 02:07 TCT · #956

I doubt it. i'm the guilty, and can freeze people in fear. however, I can only do it once. so, I doubt we have an actual escort. i'm guessing the mafia planned to sacrifice one of themselves, via having an "escort" or mafia member claim they rb'd another mafia member.

Hinotori [1996403] 26 Jul 2018, 02:10 TCT · #957

The five dead people aren't connected to my death, though :P

Raius [2045501] 26 Jul 2018, 02:12 TCT · #958

;-; less cake targets?

meh. I'm guessing we still have a doctor. Seriously though, we need to find one confirmed green and pile them with cakes.

Proxima [1879587] Wiki Editor 26 Jul 2018, 02:13 TCT · #959

Ironically that's probably me, you or panop-the-cake-vendor

Ceb [68232] Committee Committee 26 Jul 2018, 02:14 TCT · #960

Zak is a small fish. Idk nor do i care about his role at the moment as there are more urgent matters.

My suspicion rests on the Assassin. He practically roleclaimed that he could see my night action and I waited to react to see if mafia would kill him. Did they? No. They tried to kill me and Moonlily protected me.

I mailed her the first night since she is my wife and signalled to her. I gave her a signal to let me know who is green or worth keeping a vote off of and she NEVER signalled anyone as trustworthy. The only logical course for my wife to take would be to protect me.

Why? Because what Hcom3 & Auriel discussed before is completely false. Players with night actions have to make an action or they are DQ'd. So the only person she knew was green was me and why would she risk her role to protect a potential non-green? Keeping it on me is the only logical course until she can signal someone else she thinks is worth protecting.

So thats all well and dandy, but that doesnt mean Assassin is red, right? Wrong. He pushed for people to vote Moonlily if he couldn't get a pile on Zak. Lemme ask you this...why kill someone if you are going to pile at end of day like they did at the end of Day 2? You dont. You save your night kills. No one would logically make an attempt on Moonlily if she was expected to be piled.

There is no doubt in my mind. Assassin has a red or neutral spy or communication ability.

I also have limited time to play so if i dont get a chance to respond before i am killed, the other players suspicious to me are Orca (for moving votes), Hcom3 (for late pile), and lighter suspicions on Beesword, and Prox (didnt really worry about my vote. Could be that knew the late pile would happen)

Vote TheAssassain