Skip to content
TORNLIFE More

Privilege

Started by SHIR123321 [2080313] on in Politics & Law.

11 replies · 114 views · thread synced · 6 days ago · View on torn.com
About this thread

Posts archived: 12 / 12 posts (100%) · the total is Torn's reply count + the opening post at the last fetch

Counted by TornLife from the archived posts.

Archived posts
12
Discussion span
→
People posting
5
Likes on archived posts
14
Authority score
8 / 100
Historical score
11 / 100
Story score
32 / 100
Engagement score
54 / 100
porkscrew [2090183]
privilege - by definition - is granted [by peers and society]
advantage - by definition - isn’t granted; it is inherent, discovered, created

the video is weighing relative advantages under the guise of privileges, which distracts from and cheapens the reality of what privilege actually is.
the author is misleading (dare i say dishonest) for conflating/confusing these two words and their deeper meanings.
it attempts to shrink the elephant in the room and tuck it in the corner… but it’s still in the room

if a minority (ethnic/gender/sexual/religious/etc) is not granted specific privileges because the majority believes said minority doesn't deserve those privileges - whether fair or unfair, openly or secretly - while being granted such privileges themselves, then we must work to understand why that is and address it.

on the same token, if certain privileges are granted to a minority or majority, but not to others [for arbitrary reasons], we must again ask why and address it.

in my locale, as a well-spoken white American male with a local accent I don’t worry about being...:
  • profiled as suspicious/dangerous by strangers on the street
  • perceived as a possible thief browsing retail merchandise on racks and shelves
  • an immediate threat when I reach into my pocket for my phone
...because i've been arbitrarily granted privileges

turn the tables and put the same me into a time and space where the majority sees me as a smooth-talking white devil.
assuming i'm a threat to them - for their own reasons - fair or unfair;
i am not granted any privilege in this context, yet i will retain certain advantages unrelated to privilege (e.g. i can evade them with my superior dexterity if they decide to apprehend me).
This is fundamentally what the video is about: [The Theory of?] Relative Advantage.
SHIR123321 [2080313]
I disagree,
advantage -a condition or circumstance that puts one in a favorable or superior position.
privilege - a special right, advantage, or immunity granted or available only to a particular person or group.

Privilege is by definition a type of advantage, and the privilege talked about in the video is privilege by birth, almost every birth condition can be looked as positive or negative , in some sense, for example you could argue surviving a war opened your eyes, many disabled athletes see their injury as a new beginning (went for extreme cases on to prove a point), therefore everything talked in the video is indeed a relative advantages but it doesn't mean it isn't a privilege

Relative advantages are consistent with the definition of Privilege and can be a part of it.
not every Relative advantage is a privilege but all of the privileges he pointed out can be seen as relative advantages and they are also the most discussed privileges.
porkscrew [2090183]
sir, you need to read my original post. my initial point stands;

privilege is granted
e.g. i am white by birth. some grant me privilege because i'm white.
it is otherwise totally irrelevant except when i'm standing in the scorching sun

advantage granted (privilege)
vs
advantage/disadvantage born with (not a privilege)

privilege = advantage
advantage =/= privilege

if these concepts are lost on you, then i'm afraid i cannot be of any further help.

*drops mic*
SHIR123321 [2080313]
"advantage/disadvantage born with (not a privilege)"
but it is a privilege
by my definition atleast

I posted a full list of what is a privilege
you posted a condition that disagrees with it 
can you post your full list of what is a privilege? 
Viracocha [1772040]
white privilege is a myth

rich brahmins, etc. come to Canada and get government jobs etc. over whites through employment equity legislation.

such nonsense.
TangoCash [2166235]
Yea the video basically ends with privilege being a giant circle jerk because we can't see what privileges people have. All people are born into different environments and have different privileges.