Skip to content
TORNLIFE More

The Bingham Protocol

Started by MRchoi [3998961] on in Politics & Law.

11 replies · 30 views · thread synced · 5 days ago · View on torn.com
About this thread

Posts archived: 12 / 12 posts (100%) · the total is Torn's reply count + the opening post at the last fetch

Counted by TornLife from the archived posts.

Archived posts
12
Discussion span
→
People posting
7
Likes on archived posts
15
Authority score
8 / 100
Historical score
10 / 100
Story score
31 / 100
Engagement score
51 / 100

Most-liked replies

MRchoi [3998961]

What the film is about

  • A convicted murderer is not executed.

  • Instead, the state introduces a new punishment system:

    • His arms, legs, and body parts are surgically removed over time

    • Each punishment is publicly broadcast

  • The process continues until nothing recognizably human remains

  • Society accepts it because it’s framed as justice, deterrence, and public will

    IRL Question

    If given the chance to enact such a law in real life, would it pass?

    Do rapists, murderers, terrorists, drug dealers, and other heinous criminals deserve extreme punitive treatment rather than the death penalty?

    If a system like this were enacted for the most serious crimes, would it serve as a stronger deterrent—making potential offenders think twice before committing such acts? Or would execution be the more effective and humane option?

    Assuming life imprisonment is no longer viable in the future, as society grows increasingly desensitized and violent, which punishment better preserves order: prolonged punitive treatment or death?


    Considering the principles of human rights, do rapists, murderers, terrorists, and other heinous criminals still deserve the protection of human rights?

Hypocritical [1280905]

Without watching the movie I'm going to assume it was a critique of that sort of desire for violence retribution and that sort of eye for and eye morality is deeply flawed. I don't think you meant to walk away thinking that it could be good if implemented