I was fully convinced that this action of her would only mean either she is red or indifferent. Never have i thought someone would have a role who could give death immunity. I just assumed that mary's role hint about death immunity was about a doctor. My deep apologies. I killed one of the most useful town.
As for den's death, i think it is too early to be a bus. I also wanted to rely on dede's result but VNG said ahe was rb'd.
Also, nini's block claim could mean either 1) there are two blockers 2) gabby was bot blocked but instead, the block was redirected to nini.
Lastly, im convinced that nini is green last day phase during that bickering on who are reds, why? Because someone who does that is flagging green. But still, that Den+Jhay conspiracy was the same as before but with different scenes. :P
When that happened before, nini was green again. How could i forget.
Im soft locking nini as green for yesterday's event.
That is a good question. It was after all quite spread, no matter if she really tried claiming it or not. Did they know it to not be the case or are they thinking there is another protective?
Im putting full readlist when i wake up. Pleass try to not make like 10+ pages for me to read when i wake up. And no. I wont be lurking. Id be sleeping.
Well, at some point VNG becomes really disadvantageous to town. Like last night, he decided to block someone that is soft claiming an investigative role? Whether or not dede is, VNG's actions just seem anti-town to me.
So while I wouldn't encourage lynching a town, I would encourage lynching someone who is trying to sabotage our ability to get more information.
I haven't seen the other posts yet because I just finished catching up on page 47 so I'm about to start on 48, but, I think it's possible that he could have bussed himself if he were mafia???
I can't remember what game or when it was said, but, I remember someone in a game once saying that denmon liked bussing, if I remember it correctly???
I am going to think things over so I'm gonna take a break. Yes I am lurking but I think everyone should have an opinion of this shinanigans anyway. I'll be back later with more thoughts.
This - I think Denmon was onto something here. Was green (hence his death), and the other person that was saved in that chaos of yesterday’s voting was Ninivah.
Nini has a carefully constructed long post to defend herself as she is the obvious red at this point.
Kind of convenient that you have been ‘roleblocked’ so can’t give us any info from any N1 action, do you have anything to share from last night Nini? We had 2 other claims of being roleblocked as you say - so one of you must be lying and I think it is you.
Why would a red have started all this though? I mean, its all running perfectly for them until now. They have no reason to be desperate. Some really good roles are out, and some really good players are dead. Ninivah wasn't really in a hot seat, but still started all this and ended in this strong him or me kinda mentality yesterday already. I dont see any motivation why a non-desperate mafia would put themselves in this position. A townie? That makes sense if you were really convinced someone is mafia.
Town was putting a little bit of pressure down to vote. I randomly threw my vote thinking dede was gonna be afk and was going to change it once I could have a better read through. Den started to low key defend dede and dede plainly stated that Den was not mafia. I thought I had the jackpot and they had let two it slip they were working together. My plan was to let day 2 play out (as it got a bit fast paced) and join nini in taking the two of them down. I think nini and I saw the same thing yesterday.
Dede, sorry I used my vote for you as bait to see what Den would do.
Den and Jhay: Bandwagons Ninivah for no reason Ninivah: Makes a scene right before EOD Also Ninivah: kills the guy at night who started a bandwagon on her in the day Town: Ninivah must be red Ninivah: why do you guys think I would do such a dumb thing?
I have yet to see one proper reason for why I am red and no one who has accused me is in good standing. No one who has accused me has presented a well thought out post and all ignore me.
Does anyone care that I was roleblocked again? Does anyone care that VNG wants to kill two people for fun? That Dede is pretending to be dumb?
Last night Jhay jumped onto Mary just before end of day.
And then earlier, Jhay self-claims that he is just a vanilla green who killed Montfort as he has finished using his abilities. He might be doing reverse psychology. Not sure why he wants to claim he killed Montfort?
I could be wrong of course but normally Den when is alive day 3, he is mafia (he is a really strong player), they could kill him because of that (and possibly him being the indifferent) and because of him being green. He could be working with someone who oppose him to give the aspect that they arent teammates
I mean, the only case in which it would make sense for the mafia to claim this is if they have an extra one shot killer. Which wouldn't be impossible of course. If the mafia did not perform the second kill, a mafia claiming it would be stupid, as the townie who did the kill would counterclaim it. If the mafia has a second killer that can kill every 2 or 3 nights or soemthing it would also be stupid, cause then Jhay will be under fire the moment another extra kill appears. So either Jhay is telling the truth or Jhay is a one shot extra kill mafia.
Tbh his reasoning for the shot, while not making me happy, makes me think he is green at least, but thats just my feeling.
after reading all of ninivah's long winded post im pretty much convinced she's not maf. no mafia would go this far unless they are a good liar and knew how every single player in here thought, a lot of town wouldnt either unless they really didnt want to die and had something anything to help out us out in the remaining days i mean she could be an indifferent but i dont see a neutral going out of their way to do this sort of thing when there are other ways